Before Peters is resentenced, Barrett must decide whether he keeps the case
By Jen Schumann | Rocky Mountain Voice
A Mesa County judge has ordered the state’s attorneys to respond to a motion seeking his removal from the Tina Peters case, setting up a legal fight that will determine who presides over her resentencing—and who decides whether she remains in prison while that process unfolds.
In an April 22 order, District Court Judge Matthew Barrett directed the state to file a response “as soon as practicable,” with a deadline of April 27.
The order does not resolve the issue. It moves it forward.
Now the court must decide whether Barrett can remain on the case—and nothing else in district court moves until that question is answered.
2026-0422 ACTION TAKEN_VERIFIED MOTION TO DISQUALIFY JUDGE MATTHEW BARRETT - People Respond by 4-27Download
...









