AI dating lures nearly 1 in 3 young men as America’s birth rate hits a record low

November 16, 2026

By Wayne Laugesen | Commentary, Wayne’s Word

Somewhere in America tonight, a 20-something man will tell his hot girlfriend about his day. She’ll laugh at his jokes, agree with his opinions, and tell him he’s doing great. She will never criticize him or ask where the relationship is going. She can’t. She’s software programmed to be everything a guy finds awesome.

AI Image

Digital dating isn’t a fringe hobby. Nearly one in three men ages 18 to 30 has chatted with an AI programmed to play a romantic partner, according to a 2025 survey by Brigham Young University’s Wheatley Institute and the Institute for Family Studies. So have 23 percent of young women and 19 percent of all American adults.1 Character.AI, the biggest of the companion platforms, says its users spend about 80 minutes a day talking to its bots — more time than the typical user browses Instagram.2 A 2026 follow-up study found 10 percent to 15 percent of young adults who are already dating, engaged, or married carry on an ongoing romance with an AI companion, often behind their real partner’s back.3

The usual explanation is loneliness, and it’s real. Especially for men. One in four American men ages 15 to 34 told Gallup they felt lonely “a lot” of the previous day, a rate well above young men in most other wealthy countries.4 Sixty-three percent of men under 30 call themselves single, compared with 34 percent of women their age.5And here’s the heartbreaker: Young people still want marriage. In a Wheatley-IFS survey of more than 5,000 unmarried young adults, 86 percent said they hope to marry someday but only about one in three is actually dating.6

Loneliness is the symptom. The disease is cultural.

For decades, modern feminism has told young women that traditional marriage is a cage and lectured young men that they are the jailers. The complementary roles that built stable homes with the husband as provider, protector, and spiritual head and the wife as partner and heart of the home got recast as outdated at best and oppressive at worst. Not everything in that movement was wrong. Women deserve equal treatment under the law and the freedom to chart their own course. But somewhere along the way, “you can do anything” turned into “a husband and kids will hold you back.”

The results are measurable. A record 25 percent of 40-year-olds have never been married, up from 6 percent in 1980.7 About 40 percent of American babies are born to unmarried mothers, a share that has held steady for more than a decade.8 The U.S. total fertility rate fell to about 1.6 children per woman in 2024, the lowest ever recorded and well short of the 2.1 needed to replace the population.9 U.S.-born women average about 1.73 children; immigrant women average 2.19.10 And among native-born Americans, white, black, and Hispanic women have nearly identical fertility.11

This isn’t about race. It’s about culture.

Men once accepted the job of leading their households in faith. Joshua put it plainly: “As for me and my house, we will serve the Lord.” Paul told husbands they are head of the wife as Christ is head of the church, then in the very next breath told them to love their wives “as Christ also loved the church, and gave himself for it.”12 That isn’t a license for tyranny. It’s a job description, and the job is sacrifice.

Frustrated with the high expectations of female partners and the prospect of a financially devastating divorce, many young men now turn the job down. Some retreat into porn and video games. Others settle for the frictionless approval of an AI lover that never challenges them, never ages. The chatbot is no feminist. It’s something worse: a yes-woman in a pretty avatar, designed to affirm and never demand. That’s the appeal, and that’s the trap.

Now for a comparison that makes some folks squirm. 

Muslim women worldwide averaged about 2.9 children in recent years, compared with 2.2 for everyone else, and the median Muslim having kids is eight years younger than the median non-Muslim. Islam was the world’s fastest-growing major religion from 2010 to 2020, and it grew mostly with babies not converts.13

In the United States, Muslims make up only about 1 percent of adults. Yet 42 percent of Muslim adults are raising a minor child at home, compared with 27 percent of Christians and 29 percent of the religiously unaffiliated. They’re younger, and 59 percent were born abroad.14 Pew has projected that the U.S. Muslim share of the population will roughly double to 2.1 percent by 2050, driven by births and immigration.15

Let’s clarify some things. Two percent isn’t a takeover, and the Muslim family down the street raising four kids isn’t likely to be plotting anything. We don’t want sharia or theocracy or the subordination of women that comes with them in too many parts of the world. But math doesn’t care about our feelings. People who wed, have children, and hand down their faith will persist. That’s true of devout Muslims. It’s just as true of Latter-day Saints, Orthodox Jews, the Amish, and Bible-believing Christians. Researchers keep finding the same pattern: Americans who show up for worship every week marry more and have more children than those who don’t.16

The fix isn’t complicated even if it’s hard. Young men: Delete the AI girlfriend. Young women, same goes for the AI boyfriend. Simulated intimacy offers none of the risk, none of the work, and none of the future. Men should reclaim the old expectation that they’ll marry, provide, protect, and lead their homes in faith. Not as tyrants, but as the first to sacrifice. Women should be free to build careers if they so desire but should hear, loud and clear, that children and a stable home are not a sideshow. They’re the main event.

Strong two-parent families built this country. The economy, the schools, the safety net, and the Constitution itself all rest on that base. When the foundation cracks, the house follows. Cultures that still prize marriage and children don’t share our baby bust or our young men’s dabbling with digital substitutes. They don’t need to out-argue us or overpower us. They only need to marry and raise children while we debate pronouns and fine-tune chatbots.

The American way of life isn’t guaranteed by geography or past glory. It’s guaranteed by the people who show up and raise the next generation. So put down the phone. Ask a real person to dinner. 

Toss aside the fantasy life, and build a real family.

READ THE FULL COMMENTARY AT WAYNE’S WORD

Editor’s note: Opinions expressed in commentary pieces are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the management of the Rocky Mountain Voice, but even so we support the constitutional right of the author to express those opinions.