Anthony: Mandatory recycling destroys the economics of reuse

November 18, 2026

By Tom Anthony | Guest Commentary, Rocky Mountain Voice

I’ve long been a bargain hunter and as we all know nothing is quite as good a bargain as “free,” with the possible exception of a free haircut.

Having been a carpenter most of my life, I early on found that staying at work after hours to visit the roll-off gave me a source of tax-free income, especially since laboring Americans who build stuff tend to kick in (percentage-wise) a lot more than the “creative” class.

Consequently I’ve augmented (or built in toto) many buildings with recycled materials, and I have numerous stories about dumpster diving, alley crawling, and even landfill visits where the truck came out weighing more than when I went in.

Here’s a story about a recent dumpster diver who brought in $140,000 in sales in one year, something I’m sure is possible but who am I to brag, alert the IRS, and screw up the biz?

Nonetheless I can’t abide the new push by Front Range cities like Boulder and Denver to force people into the “good behavior” of recycling at the point of a gun, thus eliminating a source of non-taxable blue-collar income, regimenting an inventory into the supply chain, squeezing all the freedom-loving homeless into apartments and forcing all the good citizens into line at Goodwill.

I was involved in a food recycling program in Anchorage, Alaska, for a few years in which all the volunteers were paid in food, the organizer filed the 501(c)(3) docs each year, and the participating grocery stores wrote off their losses and donations of expired or damaged or blemished food to his group, “Earth,” which had zero income.

Michael and Lydia O’Callahan were the godparents of my first child.

Eventually the Food Bank of Alaska came after Earth, threatening the City of Anchorage and the food chains participating with “food safety” lawsuits, which did eventually shut it down and replace it with millions of taxpayer dollars and a roll of welfare recipients who had to register with the Food Bank to get food.

Did “the Bank” then receive and distribute this otherwise “tainted” food or did it just get dumped? No idea. Does Earth still provide a multi-variegated menu? Seems like it.

I helped recycle a vacant warehouse once, which turned into a 94-unit condo development in the Central Platte Valley, a building the Denver Storage Warehouse began constructing in 1892 and which, under Tom Gart and Brad Buchanan, now executive director of Denver’s Department of Community Planning and Development, became the Watertower Lofts, where residents get to see really for truly first-growth yellow pine beams and subfloor (ceilings).

Mandatory recycling destroys the economics of “waste not, want not” by dragging in the government, and new bureaucracy and enforcement weigh on the court systems.

According to the website OpenSecrets.org, civil servants and lawyers gave about 80% of their campaign dollars to Democrats last cycle (bully for more statutes and bureaucracy!).

This is due to the reality of “government waste,” which are two words hardly separable.

Look at Denver’s new ordinance to mandate that building owners pony up to meet new energy standards, even in pre-existing buildings that seemed to everyone using them to be completely serviceable and to use largely American-made appliances.

Lo and behold, when enforcement time came, a bunch of building owners suddenly realized what was happening, but two years too late.

So while the rest of us look at a greasy pizza box and wonder into which bin it goes, the folks currently paying the lion’s share of taxes are looking at having to circular file whole buildings.

The above seems like a roundabout way to subsidize the professional sports teams owned by Walmart heirs, by trashing perfectly good American-made and functioning products and shipping in the new goods from China, which then, of course, bring in another influx of sales tax not to mention Walmart profits they can use to further monopolize our society.

And let’s not even talk about the restaurants.

Denver’s poker game governance in the past ten years has resulted in the entire downtown teetering on a commercial real estate collapse, and now even the tenant-less building owners with tax liens have to pony up serious cash replacing perfectly functional things just to satisfy the letters in the law.

Denver’s Office of Sustainability (an oxymoronic name, with office vacancies at about 38% and restaurants declining; actual utilization of occupied space is significantly lower, since companies have adopted hybrid work models, so the reported vacancy rate measures market availability rather than the true physical emptiness of the entire building stock) says, “energy use by large buildings has dropped 9% since 2018, despite there being 400 more of them.”

That baseline pre-dates COVID, and remote work with it.

I can believe the desert of vacant office space and boarded-up storefronts consumes less energy. I did a Colorado Open Records Act request for the complex data necessary to arrive at the above conclusion, and was given a one-page statement with a graph.

The graph showed 74 fewer “large buildings” (buildings over 25,000 square feet in Denver) in 2024 than in 2023, so I guess Hogwarts vanished them after the sniffles wiped out the population.

Apparently the lawsuit “complainers” are really just speed bumps on the road to a clean sweep.

I had an experience in Boulder County recently where I saw a guy giving away his horse barn, but it had to be recycled. I met with him and apparently he had subdivided his lot and now wanted to sell the lot that had the horse barn so he could add onto his house.

Boulder said he couldn’t sell it with a vacant building on it (go get some horses, you idiot, and sell them with the lot!). Boulder also has a recycling ordinance that requires a demolition project to recycle whatever can be reused (including single-pane windows the International Building Code won’t let you reinstall).

I told him I wouldn’t consider taking down his horse barn for free if I didn’t plan to reuse the materials, and he saw the irrefutable logic, with or without the ordinances.

Of course the government has blinders which only allow it to see the subservient, obsequious, and compliant taxpayers.

I was in town with my truck and trailer and went right to work without a permit since I wasn’t coming back for a while. The job entailed breaking loose thousands of ring shank nails in first-growth Douglas fir holding galvanized steel sheets with waterproof lead washers.

Don’t tell me it was easy. It took me about three days, but I was able to save nearly all the structure and I melted the lead into balls for my flintlock.

A couple weeks later the previous owner phoned with a problem. He had to prove the demolished building had been recycled. I told him I had plans to use it all but hadn’t done any reconstruction as yet.

I sent him photos of the stack of wood and steel, and apparently that eventually got him permission to list his lot, if not to add onto his house. Don’t know how the demolition permit issue got resolved (oops).

The best book I ever read was recommended by the Whole Earth Catalog, “The $50 and up Underground House Book.”

That was before nearly every corner of the world got infected with the IBC, the new weapon against anybody who builds his own shelter. The 7th Cavalry used to handle that work, and finished at Wounded Knee.

Since the city provides trash service, the “urban waste engineers” are now conscripted as enforcers of apple core ethics. “He could have recycled this condom!” That whole thing harks back to “1984” (the book, I mean).

I’m not saying I long for the good ol’ days when I worked at $5 an hour for Swartznegger’s group, Grand American Construction, at the 1890s casket factory that became the Platte River Rowing Club, ripping out asbestos-covered pipes without so much as a dust mask (for everyone else, of course, I had mine), but since none of our elected officials seem to have ever driven a nail they’re doomed to completely seize up the “Denver” economic engine.

Want to add onto your wonderful Denver house? Just go here, for a start: demolition permits, asbestos and lead paint.

Tom Anthony lost his Denver use permit and subsequently his certificate of occupancy on his artist studio and residence for storing recycled materials in the Mixed Use Industrial zone north of I-70.

Editor’s note: Opinions expressed in commentary pieces are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the management of the Rocky Mountain Voice, but even so we support the constitutional right of the author to express those opinions.