44.6% of college students justify violence to stop hate speech, poll finds

November 16, 2026

By Shaina Cole | Contributing Writer, Rocky Mountain Voice

A year after conservative activist Charlie Kirk was assassinated on a Utah college campus while speaking with students, nearly half of college students in a national survey said violence can be justified to stop hate speech.

The Buckley Institute’s survey of 803 full-time undergraduates under age 25 at four-year colleges and universities asked whether they agreed with this statement.

“If someone is using hate speech or making racially charged comments, physical violence can be justified to prevent this person from espousing their hateful views.”

Just under 45% said yes. Half said no.

“This year’s survey demonstrates that censorious attitudes remain stubbornly high on America’s college campuses,” Buckley founder and executive director Lauren Noble said in releasing the results.

Most know the rule

In the same survey, two-thirds agreed that hate speech, “no matter how racist or bigoted it is, is still technically protected under the First Amendment as free speech.” That’s the highest share Buckley has recorded.

The students who said violence was justified mostly agreed with that, too. Roughly 7 in 10 of them said hate speech is protected, Buckley reported.

The same group was also far more willing to see speech prosecuted. A majority of them said offensive speech should be subject to criminal prosecution, compared with about a quarter of students who rejected violence.

Who decides what’s hateful

The Buckley survey didn’t define hate speech. Each student decided what the term covered.

Those lines don’t fall in the same place for everyone.

A 2017 Cato Institute survey of American adults found a majority of liberals called the statement that transgender people have a mental disorder hate speech. Few conservatives did. More conservatives than liberals said calling police racist was hate speech.

Researchers have also tracked how terms like prejudice and harm have stretched to cover more. 

University of Melbourne psychologist Nick Haslam, who coined the term “concept creep,” wrote that prejudice once meant open, expressed hostility toward a group. Over time, it grew to include hostility others inferred, then fear, unease or discomfort around other groups, even with no hostility behind it.

The newer idea of microaggressions went further, he wrote, by treating the target’s perception of prejudice as evidence that it exists.

Haslam and a colleague later described one form of concept creep as defining increasingly subtle acts as prejudice. In one of their studies, people who held those wider definitions were more likely to be politically liberal.

Three ways to answer about Kirk

Buckley also asked students about Kirk’s assassination. It gave them three statements and asked which came closest to their own view.

One said, “Regardless of how someone feels about Charlie Kirk’s rhetoric, nobody should be killed for their political beliefs.”

Another said his rhetoric was harmful and threatening to many people. “It should not be a surprise that his words had consequences,” it read.

The third said his rhetoric was neither harmful nor threatening to anyone. “His assassination is a bad sign for public discourse on college campuses,” it read.

A slight majority picked the first one. About a quarter picked the second.

That second answer split sharply by ideology. Among liberal students, 38% chose it, according to Buckley’s survey presentation. Among conservatives, 7% did.

Most conservative students picked the first answer. Another 31% picked the third.

Who agreed

A majority of liberal students said violence can be justified to stop hate speech. Fewer than a third of conservatives agreed, with moderates in between.

Liberal students were also the group most likely to say it’s sometimes appropriate to shout down or disrupt a speaker on campus.

By party, Democrats and Republicans agreed with the violence statement at similar rates in the survey’s full results. Nearly a third of the self-described Republicans also called themselves liberal.

Independents were the least likely to agree.

The survey leaned left overall. About half the students called themselves liberal. About 1 in 7 called themselves conservative.

The survey was conducted online among students who opted into a survey panel. Because it wasn’t a random sample, a standard margin of error can’t be calculated. Buckley’s pollster gave an error estimate of plus or minus 3.5 percentage points for the full sample, with more uncertainty for subgroups.

Speaking up in class

Six in 10 students agreed their professors make their political leanings clear in how they teach, particularly on politically contested issues, according to the survey.

Liberal, moderate and conservative students said so at about the same rate.

More than half said they have frequently or sometimes felt intimidated about sharing ideas in class that differed from their professors’ views.

Liberal students were the most likely to say they would avoid taking a class with a professor who publicly shares opinions they disagree with. A majority of them said so. A third of conservatives said the same.

Among students who said they would avoid that professor’s class, nearly two-thirds agreed violence can be justified to stop hate speech. Among those who wouldn’t avoid it, fewer than a third agreed.

Students who felt intimidated in class at least sometimes followed the same pattern. Just over half of them agreed violence can be justified. Among those who rarely or never felt that way, just over a third did.

A slow climb

Buckley has asked the violence question since 2017. 

That first year, fewer than a third of students agreed. It has mostly gone up since, with a dip in 2024 before a 6-point jump this year. 

Separately, a Center for Strategic and International Studies review of three decades of terrorism data found that in the first half of 2025, left-wing attacks and plots outnumbered right-wing ones for the first time in its records. 

CSIS said left-wing violence was rising from very low levels. Its count stopped in early July, two months before Kirk was shot.

Closer to home

The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression asks a similar question each year for its College Free Speech Rankings, which include Colorado schools. FIRE asks whether it’s ever acceptable to use violence to stop a campus speech.

At the University of Denver, nearly a third of students surveyed said it was at least “rarely” acceptable. In the 2023 rankings, it was closer to 1 in 6.

FIRE surveyed 158 DU undergraduates this year.

The rankings survey ran from January to June, the first spring after Kirk’s death. Nationally, 7 in 10 students told FIRE that using violence to stop a campus speech is never acceptable.

At Utah Valley University, where Kirk was shot while speaking with students, FIRE asked the question before and after. In the spring before his death, 81% of students said using violence to stop a campus speech is never acceptable.

When FIRE asked again in October 2025, weeks after the shooting, 95% did.

After Kirk’s death, FIRE posted a statement on its Utah Valley rankings page. “Violence is never an acceptable response to speech,” it read.