Laugesen: Throwing billions at schools won’t fix them

November 19, 2026

By Wayne Laugesen | Commentary, Wayne’s Word

Colorado voters just handed the education establishment a fat new check, and they didn’t ask what it buys.

Amendment 87 squeaked through with about 51.4% of the vote.1 It scraps the flat income tax Colorado has had since 1987 and replaces it with higher rates on income above $500,000.2 Supporters say it will bring in about $2 billion annually.3 I contend it will bring in nearly nothing after it runs high earners to greener pastures.

Proposition NN passed more comfortably, by nearly 12 points.4 It raises the Taxpayer’s Bill of Rights (TABOR) revenue cap so the state can keep money that would otherwise go back to taxpayers as refunds, and for the next decade that money goes to K-12 schools.5 State analysts pegged the K-12 allocation at roughly $500 million a year.6

Together, the two measures could bring the state more than $2 billion in their first full year, much of it earmarked for education.7

The pitch was the familiar one: better teacher pay, smaller classes, better results. Nobody argues with those objectives. The trouble is the track record. Colorado’s public schools already leave a lot of kids behind, and families are walking away from them in large numbers. Pouring more money into the same system, without changing how it works, is a hope. It isn’t a plan.

Look at the scores

The 2026 Colorado Measures of Academic Success (CMAS) tells the story; the CMAS measures how well students have mastered basic academic standards. Only 44.7% of students in grades three through eight met or exceeded expectations in English. In math, it was 37.3%.8

To be fair, math scores have now risen four years in a row and hit a record high.8 Good. But a record high of 37% means nearly two of every three kids still aren’t doing math at grade level. That’s not a victory lap. That’s a starting line.

High school is no better. Only 31.6% of 11th graders met the SAT math benchmark this year, down from last year.9

The gap between poor kids and everyone else is a canyon. Just 26.5% of low-income students met expectations in English language arts, compared with 58.9% of their classmates from better-off families.10 

That’s why poor families need school choice, which the left wants to demolish.

Even the state’s report cards are generous. A new Keystone Policy Center report found 146 schools carrying Colorado’s top “Performance” rating where fewer than one in three students meet grade-level benchmarks in reading and writing.11 If that earns a top grade, the grading scale needs work.

The kids are leaving

Meanwhile, the customers are heading for the exits. Colorado’s public-school enrollment peaked at 913,223 students in 2019-20.12 The October 2025 count came in at about 871,000, a one-year drop of more than 10,000 students and the largest since the first year of the pandemic.13 That’s roughly 42,000 fewer kids than at the peak.

All 10 of the state’s largest districts lost students, and so did nine of the 10 smallest.14Denver Public Schools lost nearly 1,800 more this fall, and the superintendent says school closures may be coming.15

Officials point to falling birth rates and slower migration, and those are real issues. But the state also reports a clear shift toward online schools and homeschooling.16 Full-time homeschooling is up 19.5% since 2022.17

A lot of these families aren’t leaving Colorado. They’re leaving the system.

Here’s a detail worth a taxpayer’s attention: From 2021-22 to 2025-26, Colorado’s public schools added 263 administrators, a 13.1% increase, while serving 15,724 fewer students.18

Money hasn’t been the problem

This is not a system starved for cash. Colorado’s K-12 spending rose from about $17,400 per student in 2019 to $19,757 in 2024, after adjusting for inflation.19 The Common Sense Institute found per-pupil spending has climbed substantially since 2013 without producing measurable gains on standardized tests.20

The national picture looks the same. Inflation-adjusted funding per student rose 35.8% from 2002 to 2023, according to the Reason Foundation.21 New Hampshire’s school spending grew 60.5%, the fourth-highest increase in the country, while its enrollment fell faster than any other state’s enrollment.22 If money alone bought results we’d have seen them by now.

Money can help when it’s spent well. No serious person says otherwise. But Amendment 87 and Proposition NN deliver the cash without the reforms that would make it count: more school choice, real accountability for results, and an honest look at why so many parents are opting out.

Nearly half the state voted against Amendment 87, and everyone will pay for what comes next. The least Coloradans deserve in return is a system that turns more money into kids who can read and do math. So far, the record says don’t hold your breath.

READ THE FULL COMMENTARY AT WAYNE’S WORD

Editor’s note: Opinions expressed in commentary pieces are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the management of the Rocky Mountain Voice, but even so we support the constitutional right of the author to express those opinions.